None

Displaying a painting by the renowned Renaissance artist Raphael has typically been reserved for prestigious art venues like the Louvre in Paris, the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and the Vatican Museums. However, this week, a gallery in the city of Bradford in England showcased a work that artificial intelligence (AI) has identified as being by Raphael, who is often mentioned alongside Michelangelo and Leonardo da Vinci. The exhibition, called the de Brécy Tondo, aims to settle a long-standing debate about the painting's origins and enable it to be recognized alongside Raphael's other works displayed in prominent art institutions. This two-month exhibition at the Cartwright Hall Art Gallery demonstrates how AI models could revolutionize the field of professional art attribution, which has traditionally been dependent on experts who spend their entire careers studying a single artist or period. The researchers from the Universities of Nottingham and Bradford stated in January that their AI-powered facial recognition model showed a 97 percent similarity between the Virgin Mary portrayed in the disputed de Brécy Tondo painting and Raphael's confirmed Sistine Madonna. It also identified an 86 percent similarity between the child in the painting and the Jesus figure in Raphael's altarpiece. Despite dissent from some experts, Hassan Ugail, a professor of visual computing at the University of Bradford who developed the model, believes that this case highlights the need for art connoisseurs to modernize their approaches. Ugail emphasizes that the model he created focuses on "dimensions the human eye can't see, " providing a new perspective in art analysis. The stakes of art attribution are substantial financially, as Richard Polsky, an authentication expert, explains. The addition of a newly attributed work to the market can command a significant price, especially if it has been held privately for centuries. While some artists have a well-established catalog of authenticated works, many others do not.
Therefore, scholars and the art market must achieve consensus when evaluating potential new pieces that could alter perceptions of an artist and fetch high prices. Supporters of employing AI in this process argue that it will contribute to a fairer attribution system by reducing the reliance on the judgment of a single human expert and minimizing the potential for errors, subjectivity, or biases. Carina Popovici, the CEO of AI authentication firm Art Recognition, asserts that their algorithm has accurately identified paintings forged by Wolfgang Beltracchi, a notorious art forger. Nevertheless, regarding the de Brécy Tondo, experts specialized in Raphael and Renaissance art approach the AI model's results with skepticism. The painting was acquired by a private collector in 1981, who later entrusted it to experts for study due to its resemblance to the Sistine Madonna. Some claim it to be an original Raphael work, while others argue that it is a copy created anytime between the artist's lifetime and the 19th century. Art historian Rudolf Hiller von Gaertringen, co-author of a comprehensive study on Raphael's works, doubts that the artist would have produced a copy of figures featured in the Sistine Madonna during the height of his career in the 1510s, as he preferred to explore diverse subjects. Patricia Emison, an Italian Renaissance expert, shares this sentiment, stating that it would be beneath Raphael's artistic integrity to reproduce the Madonna and child motif seen in the Sistine Madonna. Both Emison and Polsky express uncertainty regarding whether an AI model can discern the nuances that experts perceive when analyzing a work of art. Despite the reservations of traditional art experts, AI is increasingly becoming a prominent aspect of the art world. While a final, definitive decision on the de Brécy Tondo's true origin may prove challenging to ascertain, the influence of AI in the field continues to grow.
Brief news summary
None
AI-powered Lead Generation in Social Media
and Search Engines
Let AI take control and automatically generate leads for you!

I'm your Content Manager, ready to handle your first test assignment
Learn how AI can help your business.
Let’s talk!
Hot news

Kinexys Launches Carbon Market Blockchain Tokeniz…
Kinexys by J.P. Morgan, the firm’s leading blockchain business unit, is developing an innovative blockchain application on Kinexys Digital Assets, its multi-asset tokenization platform, aimed at tokenizing global carbon credits at the registry level.

Ford CEO Jim Farley warns AI will wipe out half o…
Ford CEO Jim Farley recently emphasized the critical role of the “essential economy” and blue-collar skilled trades while forecasting that artificial intelligence will halve the number of white-collar jobs in the U.S. He has become the latest executive to raise concerns over AI’s impact on workers, joining voices like Amazon’s CEO, who last month announced that the company’s corporate workforce will shrink because of AI.

Cryptocurrency Theft Losses Reach Record High in …
In the first quarter of 2025, the cryptocurrency industry saw a dramatic surge in theft losses, totaling an unprecedented $1.63 billion.

AI in Education: Personalized Learning Experiences
In recent years, the education sector has experienced a notable shift toward integrating artificial intelligence (AI) to enhance learning experiences.

New Push for National AI Rules Likely After State…
A recent effort to impose a decade-long moratorium on state-level artificial intelligence (AI) regulations through the Republican budget bill, led by Senator Ted Cruz and supported by industry groups, has faced significant setbacks, revealing the growing complexities of AI governance in the U.S. The proposal aimed to prevent states from enacting individual AI policies to avoid a fragmented regulatory landscape that could hinder innovation and burden multi-state companies.

Investors Pile into Tokenised Treasury Funds
Crypto companies and investors are increasingly channeling funds into tokenised versions of money market and Treasury bond mutual funds as alternatives to stablecoins for parking excess cash while earning yield.

What is Blockchain? Demystifying the ledger that …
Best known as the technology powering Bitcoin, blockchain is emerging as a trustless, tamper-proof system with the capacity to revolutionize sectors from finance to healthcare.